Sydney’s Bayside Council has halted intentions to de-amalgamate after community rebuffed the plan.
A recent council survey asked residents whether they would agree to pay extra rates or a $600 one-off fee to pay for demerger costs, estimated at around $50 million. The answer that came back was a resounding no. “Large unnecessary cost for little benefit”, was the general community consensus.
Bayside Council was the result of a forced merger of the City of Botany Bay and the City of Rockdale councils in 2019.
With a population of around 182,000 residents, the Bayside local government area stretches over 29 of Sydney’s southern and south-eastern suburbs – including Arncliffe, Banksia, Rockdale, Kogarah and Wolli Creek.
Earlier this year, the NSW government introduced legislation that provides a legal pathway for forcibly merged councils to part ways.
However, there’s a catch for councils wanting to take up the opportunity to de-amalgamate. The legislation requires councils that want to divorce to fund their own de-amalgamation, and to have the backing of the majority of the community – which was far from forthcoming from Bayside residents who overwhelmingly gave the thumbs down, with 79% of 401 respondents preferring council to remain as is.
As a result, council last week voted to halt the move – unless the state government either foots the bill or reverses the decision of the previous Liberal government. Cr Michael Nagi – who moved the motion – said on the night of the vote: “I just want to put this to bed and if someone is serious about de-amalgamation, let the state government deal with it.”
With a population of around 182,000 residents – the Bayside local government area – Bayside residents overwhelmingly gave the thumbs down, with 79% of 401 respondents preferring council to remain as is – 79% of 401 residents is 371 residents. Overwhelmingly, the other 181,629 residents gave the thumbs down??? This repeats itself in other councils like Randwick Council I know about. Time councils stop this.
You would definitely have to question the percentage of residents who were originally included in this research project. Not an adequate sample size in my opinion. You would also hope it was equally representative of both merged areas and suburbs within in addition to other demographic representation.
Having had the privilege of working professionally with councils in Queensland such as Brisbane City Council, Gold Coast City Council and Moreton Bay Regional Council as well as some of the larger councils in NSW such as Blacktown City Council where I also live, I think there is a lot to be said for larger LGAs rather than smaller. More and better services at lower costs with specialist staff to deal with particular issues rather than engineers and others having to be Jacks of all trades. Personally, I think there would be benefit in further amalgamations across Sydney LGAs.