Paul Ronald Whyte, a former assistant director general of corporate operations at the WA Department of Communities, was to all appearances “the epitome of a successful senior public servant”.
But in reality, the 58-year-old was an “inveterate gambler” who stole more than $22 million that could have been used to provide affordable housing and frittered it away on an extravagant lifestyle amounting to about $160,000 a year.
Between 2013-2019 he gambled more than $813, 000 and lost $732,000, while a TAB account opened in the name of his partner lost $88,500.
In a report tabled in parliament this week, the state’s Corruption and Crime Commission CCC reveals how a single piece of information from a government credit card led to the uncovering of Australia’s biggest corruption by a public servant.
In short My Whyte was the ideal public servant. Except it was all a lie.
WA CCC
Whyte, who oversaw large-scale government procurement, internal governance, integrity and corporate assurance in his role, has since pleaded guilty to 564 charges of corruption and money laundering and will be sentenced in the Supreme Court, where the full details of his activities are expected to come to light.
Credit card misuse
In its report the WA Corruption and Crime Commission (CCC) reveals how information it received in 2018 relating to a government credit card brought about Whyte’s undoing.
The CCC says red flags a relating to Whyte’s lifestyle and finances already abounded included expensive property, interests in 87 racehorses, heavy gambling and mystery payments to his bank accounts.
The investigation also revealed the outright purchase of a property registered in Whyte’s partner’s name in 2013 for $3 million.
“A picture was emerging and suspicions in respect to Mr Whyte were growing but it was still unknown how his lifestyle was funded, although he was clearly living beyond his apparent means, the CCC said.
The breakthrough came in August 2019, a number of months after preliminary investigations had been underway, when analysis of Whyte’s government credit cards matched payments into companies he controlled.
For more than a decade, he rapaciously stole more than $22 million from the state while maintaining a facade of professionalism.
WA CCC
It was revealed that since 2009 Whyte had been using his corporate credit card to transfer $50,000 a month. Subsequent surveillance found he was personally authorising pament of false invoices to the value of $100,000 a month to a number of shell companies.
“What had emerged was a clear and continuing threat to the public purse,” the CCC said. “Swift action was needed to protect state funds”.
That discovery set in a motion a chain of events that by October of that year resulted in WA police executing search warrants, arresting Whyte and his assets being frozen.
Departmental culture to come under scrutiny
The CCE says its investigations included painstaking reviews of terabytes of data and mountains of files dating back more than a decade and the involvement of a team of investigators, intelligence analysts , digital forensic specialists and covert surveillance teams.
“What is clear is that the smallest piece of information or evidence can eventually lead to the discovery of serious and significant corrupt and criminal activity,” the CCC said.
The commission has foreshadowed further reports on the culture within government departments that allowed Whyte’s corruption to flourish.
Four of Whyte’s associates have also been charged with various offences and are yet to be dealt with by the courts.
To be very frank – specific employees of the WA Government should be scrutinised for potential corruption (aiding and abetting the criminal) and running weak financial reporting systems. I never liked the idea of handing out corporate cards to anyone – always the risk of a “bad apple” aided and abetted by weak accounting and auditing.
This article both shocks and boggles the mind. How can this kind of behaviour go un-noticed for the length of time. Isn’t auditing a standard procedure within Goverment Departments? What’s happened here? I just can’t go past – WHY WHY did this take place in a goverment Department with no checks in place. I am flabbergasted and bafflled. I want to see his supervisor indicted as an accomplise.
A credit card that you can spend $150,000 per month on as a government employee? Unbelievable.
Credit cards have credit limits and daily amounts that can be set. Credit cards also can be set to no cash out. This is almost incomprehensible on the accounts department that set this card up… let alone the folly the ensued from there on…with no checks and balances. Corporate credit cards should never be setup in a manner that is asking for abuse, they are for low ticket items. Larger items you write a cheque, yes you can still do that….or you EFT.
no need to write any more….just shake my head
Until the penalties for these corporate crimes match the offence and I don’t mean a slap on the wrist, these crimes against society will continue. Total and complete loss of all personal assets must be the starting point.
Sham invoicing has got to be the easiest way to commit fraud. To even begin to tackle the problem, there has to be random audits of monies spent by local government through tracing the expenditure back to the invoice source and even to analyse the books of the company issuing the invoice because sham invoices come from sham businesses for sham products and services run by sham directors or crooked affiliates.